Retirement2 min read

By Dhirendra Kumar SinghEx-Indian Air Force · AMFI-registered MFD, ARN-152682
At discharge you are asked a question that shapes the next fifteen years: how much of your pension do you want to commute? The lump sum is tempting. The reduced pension is permanent for a long time. Here is a calm way to think about it.
ShareWhatsApp (opens in a new tab)LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)

What commutation is
Commutation lets you exchange a portion of your monthly pension for a one-time payment. In return, your pension is reduced by the commuted portion for a fixed number of years, after which the full pension is restored.
The percentage you may commute, the factor used to calculate the lump sum and the restoration period are set by the rules in force when you retire. Take the exact figures from your pension sanction papers, not from hearsay.
The case for taking the lump sum
A lump sum gives you choices. It can clear a home loan, fund a child’s education that is only a few years away, or become the seed capital for a second career.
The commuted amount is, under current rules, received tax-free by defence personnel, which makes it more efficient than drawing the same money later as taxable income. Confirm the present tax position before relying on this.
Commutation only makes sense if the lump sum has a job to do.
The case for keeping the pension
A pension is an income you cannot outlive and cannot lose in a market fall. It rises with dearness relief. For a family with no other steady income, that certainty is worth a great deal.
If you commute and then leave the money idle in a savings account, you have swapped a rising income for a shrinking pile. Commutation only makes sense if the lump sum has a job to do.
A practical way to decide
List what the lump sum would be used for and when. Money needed within three years is usually kept in lower-risk instruments. Money that can stay invested for ten years or more is generally considered able to take measured market risk. If part of it is meant to top up the monthly income, the SWP calculator shows how long a chosen withdrawal could last at an assumed return.
Then check the household budget on the reduced pension. If the family can live comfortably on it, commutation is affordable. If not, commute less. We work through these numbers with families as part of goal and retirement planning.

Dhirendra Kumar Singh
Served twenty years in the Indian Air Force before becoming an AMFI-registered Mutual Fund Distributor (ARN-152682) and licensed Insurance Advisor in Gorakhpur.
Read his storyShareWhatsApp (opens in a new tab)LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)
Related
Goals & Retirement
Pension, commutation, gratuity and provident fund put on one page, with a purpose for each lump sum.
Read about Goals & RetirementThis article is for general education. It is not tax, legal or investment advice, and rules change over time. Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks. Please read all scheme related documents carefully before investing. Insurance is the subject matter of solicitation.

